# 🧪 Test Execution Results

**Test Date:** 2026-05-09
**Tester:** AI Testing Agent
**Environment:** Development
**Laravel Version:** Check via `php artisan --version`

---

## 📊 Test Summary

### Overall Statistics
- **Total Test Cases Planned:** 150+
- **Test Cases Executed:** [In Progress]
- **Passed:** ✅ [Count]
- **Failed:** ❌ [Count]
- **Skipped:** ⏭️ [Count]
- **Pass Rate:** [XX%]

---

## ✅ PRE-FLIGHT CHECKS

### Structure Verification
- ✅ **Controllers Verified:** All 31 Frontend controllers exist
- ✅ **Views Verified:** All 27 Frontend views exist
- ✅ **Key Controllers Present:**
  - SkripsiRegistrationController
  - MbkmRegistrationController
  - SkripsiSeminarController
  - MbkmSeminarController
  - SkripsiDefenseController
  - ApplicationScheduleController
  - ApplicationResultSeminarController
  - ApplicationResultDefenseController
  - ApplicationReportController
  - ApplicationController
  
### Key Views Present:
- ✅ `/frontend/skripsi/create.blade.php` (Skripsi Reguler Registration)
- ✅ `/frontend/mbkm/create.blade.php` (MBKM Registration)
- ✅ `/frontend/skripsiSeminars/` (index, create, show, edit)
- ✅ `/frontend/mbkmSeminars/` (index, create, show, edit)
- ✅ `/frontend/skripsiDefenses/` (create, show, edit)
- ✅ `/frontend/applicationSchedules/` (create, index, show)
- ✅ `/frontend/applicationResultSeminars/` (create, show)
- ✅ `/frontend/applicationResultDefenses/` (create, show)
- ✅ `/frontend/applicationReports/` (index, create, show)

---

## 🎯 TEST EXECUTION BY PHASE

### PHASE 1: SKRIPSI REGULER WORKFLOW

#### Test Group 1.1: Registration (Mahasiswa)
**Form:** `/frontend/skripsi/create`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-001 | Access form with valid mahasiswa account | ⏳ Pending | Need to test |
| TC-SR-002 | Fill all required fields | ⏳ Pending | Multi-step wizard |
| TC-SR-003 | Upload KHS document | ⏳ Pending | PDF, max 10MB |
| TC-SR-004 | Upload KRS document | ⏳ Pending | PDF, max 10MB |
| TC-SR-005 | Submit form with valid data | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-006 | Verify file naming convention | ⏳ Pending | SKRIPSI_KHS_{NIM}... |
| TC-SR-007 | Test Select2 dropdown | ⏳ Pending | Should not clip |
| TC-SR-008 | Test wizard navigation | ⏳ Pending | Next/prev buttons |
| TC-SR-009 | Validation: missing fields | ⏳ Pending | Should show error |
| TC-SR-010 | Validation: file size exceeds | ⏳ Pending | Should reject |
| TC-SR-011 | Validation: wrong file format | ⏳ Pending | Non-PDF rejected |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.2: Admin Verification
**Page:** `/admin/skripsi-registrations`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-012 | View pending registrations list | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-013 | Open registration detail | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-014 | View uploaded documents | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-015 | Approve registration | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-016 | Reject with notes | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-017 | Verify status changes | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.3: Assign Pembimbing
**Page:** `/admin/application-assignments/create`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-019 | Create assignment | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-020 | Assign as pembimbing | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-021 | Assign as reviewer | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-022 | Set assignment date | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-023 | Save assignment | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-024 | Verify in dosen dashboard | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.4: Dosen Review
**Page:** `/dosen/task-assignments` & `/dosen/review-proposal`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-025 | View assigned tasks | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-026 | Click Review button | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-027 | Navigate to review page | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-028 | View mahasiswa info | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-029 | View proposal documents | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-030 | Select decision (approved/revision/rejected) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-031 | Enter score (0-100) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-032 | Enter feedback | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-033 | Enter revision notes | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-034 | Submit review | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-035 | Verify status update | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.5: Skripsi Seminar Registration
**Page:** `/frontend/skripsi-seminars/create`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-036 | Access seminar form | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-037 | Check access control | ⏳ Pending | After stage 5 only |
| TC-SR-038 | Fill title field | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-039 | Fill description | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-040 | Upload proposal (required) | ⏳ Pending | Max 10MB |
| TC-SR-041 | Upload approval (required) | ⏳ Pending | Max 10MB |
| TC-SR-042 | Upload plagiarism (required) | ⏳ Pending | Max 10MB |
| TC-SR-043 | Enter notes (optional) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-044 | Submit registration | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-045 | Validation: missing files | ⏳ Pending | Should error |
| TC-SR-046 | View in list | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.6: Admin Verify Seminar
**Page:** `/admin/skripsi-seminars`

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-047 | View pending seminars | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-048 | Open seminar detail | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-049 | Download documents | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-050 | Approve seminar | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-051 | Reject with notes | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.7: Schedule Creation
**Page:** `/frontend/application-schedules/create`
**Priority:** High

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-053 | Access schedule form | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-054 | Select schedule type | ⏳ Pending | skripsi_seminar |
| TC-SR-055 | Select date (future) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-056 | Select time | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-057 | Choose location (offline) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-058 | Select room | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-059 | Enter meeting link (online) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-060 | Enter notes | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-061 | Submit schedule | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-062 | View in list | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.8: Report Seminar Result
**Page:** `/frontend/application-result-seminars/create`

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-067 | Access result form | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-068 | Select result (passed/revision/failed) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-069 | Set revision deadline | ⏳ Pending | If revision |
| TC-SR-070 | Enter reviewer notes | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-071 | Upload report documents | ⏳ Pending | Multiple |
| TC-SR-072 | Upload attendance | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-073 | Upload assessment forms | ⏳ Pending | Multiple |
| TC-SR-074 | Submit result | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.9: Defense Registration
**Page:** `/frontend/skripsi-defenses/create`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-076 | Access defense form | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-077 | Check access control | ⏳ Pending | After seminar passed |
| TC-SR-078 | Enter thesis title | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-079 | Enter abstract | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-080 | Upload thesis (max 20MB) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-081 | Upload approval | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-082 | Upload plagiarism | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-083 | Upload revision proof (optional) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-084 | Enter notes | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-085 | Submit defense | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 1.10: Dosen Scoring
**Page:** `/dosen/scoring/{application}`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-SR-091 | Access scoring page | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-SR-092 | Enter overall score | ⏳ Pending | 0-100 |
| TC-SR-093 | Enter component scores | ⏳ Pending | Optional |
| TC-SR-094 | Select grade letter | ⏳ Pending | A, B+, B, etc. |
| TC-SR-095 | Enter comments | ⏳ Pending | Required |
| TC-SR-096 | Select recommendation | ⏳ Pending | Pass/revision/fail |
| TC-SR-097 | Submit scoring | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

### PHASE 2: SKRIPSI MBKM WORKFLOW

#### Test Group 2.1: MBKM Registration
**Page:** `/frontend/mbkm/create`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-MBKM-001 | Access MBKM form | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-002 | Fill student info | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-003 | Enter MBKM program details | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-004 | Upload MBKM certificate | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-005 | Upload KHS | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-006 | Upload KRS | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-007 | Select research group | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-008 | Submit registration | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-009 | Verify wizard navigation | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 2.2: MBKM Seminar Registration
**Page:** `/frontend/mbkm-seminars/create`
**Priority:** Critical

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-MBKM-015 | Access MBKM seminar form | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-016 | Fill MBKM title | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-017 | Fill description | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-018 | Upload proposal (required) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-019 | Upload approval (required) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-020 | Upload plagiarism (required) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-021 | Submit MBKM seminar | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-MBKM-022 | View in list | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

### PHASE 3: CROSS-CUTTING FEATURES

#### Test Group 3.1: Timeline Component
**Component:** `components/thesis-timeline.blade.php`
**Priority:** High

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-TL-001 | Timeline for Skripsi (10 stages) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-TL-002 | Timeline for MBKM (11 stages) | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-TL-003 | Current stage highlighted | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-TL-004 | Completed stages checkmark | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-TL-005 | Pending stages gray | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-TL-006 | Status badges correct | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-TL-007 | Compact mode in modal | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-TL-008 | Vertical mode in detail | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 3.2: Application Reports
**Page:** `/frontend/application-reports/*`
**Priority:** Medium

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-REP-001 | Create issue report | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-REP-002 | Set priority | ⏳ Pending | Low/medium/high |
| TC-REP-003 | Enter description | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-REP-004 | Upload evidence | ⏳ Pending | Multiple files |
| TC-REP-005 | Submit report | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-REP-006 | View report status | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-REP-007 | Admin views reports | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-REP-008 | Admin responds | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 3.3: Admin Dashboard
**Page:** `/admin`
**Priority:** High

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-ADM-001 | View statistics | ⏳ Pending | All cards |
| TC-ADM-002 | Pending verifications count | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-ADM-003 | View recent applications | ⏳ Pending | Last 10 |
| TC-ADM-004 | Quick actions work | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 3.4: Monitoring Dashboard
**Page:** `/admin/monitoring`
**Priority:** High

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-ADM-005 | View all applications | ⏳ Pending | With timeline |
| TC-ADM-006 | Timeline visible | ⏳ Pending | Each application |
| TC-ADM-007 | Pembimbing info | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-ADM-008 | Pagination works | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-ADM-009 | Detail links work | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

#### Test Group 3.5: Dosen Dashboard Features
**Page:** `/dosen/*`
**Priority:** High

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| TC-DOS-001 | Dashboard statistics | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-DOS-002 | Recent assignments | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-DOS-003 | Mahasiswa bimbingan list | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-DOS-004 | Timeline modal | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-DOS-005 | Task assignments page | ⏳ Pending | |
| TC-DOS-006 | Scores page | ⏳ Pending | |

**Group Status:** ⏳ Not Started

---

## 🐛 REGRESSION TESTS (Previous Bug Fixes)

| Bug ID | Description | Status | Verification |
|--------|-------------|--------|--------------|
| BUG-001 | Modal glitch on dosen/task-assignments | ⏳ Pending | Should not glitch |
| BUG-002 | Select2 dropdown clipping | ⏳ Pending | Should not clip |
| BUG-003 | Wizard form navigation not working | ⏳ Pending | Next/prev should work |
| BUG-004 | Carbon date parsing errors | ⏳ Pending | No errors expected |
| BUG-005 | File upload validation "must be string" | ⏳ Pending | Should accept file objects |

---

## 🔒 SECURITY TESTS

| Test ID | Test Case | Status | Notes |
|---------|-----------|--------|-------|
| SEC-001 | Mahasiswa cannot access admin | ⏳ Pending | 403 expected |
| SEC-002 | Mahasiswa cannot access dosen | ⏳ Pending | 403 expected |
| SEC-003 | Dosen cannot access admin | ⏳ Pending | 403 expected |
| SEC-004 | Dosen only sees own assignments | ⏳ Pending | |
| SEC-005 | Mahasiswa only sees own apps | ⏳ Pending | |
| SEC-006 | CSRF protection works | ⏳ Pending | |
| SEC-007 | SQL injection prevented | ⏳ Pending | Eloquent protects |

---

## 📱 RESPONSIVE TESTS

| Device | Resolution | Status | Issues |
|--------|------------|--------|--------|
| Desktop | 1920x1080 | ⏳ Pending | |
| Laptop | 1366x768 | ⏳ Pending | |
| Tablet | 768x1024 | ⏳ Pending | |
| Mobile | 375x667 | ⏳ Pending | |

---

## 🌐 BROWSER COMPATIBILITY

| Browser | Version | Status | Issues |
|---------|---------|--------|--------|
| Chrome | Latest | ⏳ Pending | |
| Firefox | Latest | ⏳ Pending | |
| Edge | Latest | ⏳ Pending | |
| Safari | Latest | ⏳ Pending | |

---

## 📋 CRITICAL ISSUES FOUND

### Critical (Blocker)
*None found yet*

### High (Must fix before production)
*TBD after testing*

### Medium (Should fix)
*TBD after testing*

### Low (Nice to have)
*TBD after testing*

---

## 🎯 TESTING PROGRESS

### Completed Test Groups: 0 / 15
- [ ] SR-1.1: Registration
- [ ] SR-1.2: Admin Verification
- [ ] SR-1.3: Assign Pembimbing
- [ ] SR-1.4: Dosen Review
- [ ] SR-1.5: Seminar Registration
- [ ] SR-1.6: Admin Verify Seminar
- [ ] SR-1.7: Schedule Creation
- [ ] SR-1.8: Report Seminar Result
- [ ] SR-1.9: Defense Registration
- [ ] SR-1.10: Dosen Scoring
- [ ] MBKM-2.1: MBKM Registration
- [ ] MBKM-2.2: MBKM Seminar
- [ ] Cross-3.1: Timeline Component
- [ ] Cross-3.2: Application Reports
- [ ] Cross-3.3: Admin Dashboard
- [ ] Cross-3.4: Monitoring Dashboard
- [ ] Cross-3.5: Dosen Features

---

## 📝 TEST NOTES

### Testing Environment Notes:
- Database: [MySQL/PostgreSQL/SQLite]
- PHP Version: [Check]
- Laravel Version: [Check]
- Server: php artisan serve

### Test Data Requirements:
- Need 3 mahasiswa accounts with valid data
- Need 3 dosen accounts
- Need 1 admin account
- Need sample PDF files (1MB, 5MB, 10MB, 15MB)

### Known Limitations:
- Cannot test email notifications without mail server
- Cannot test real-time features without websockets
- PDF preview requires PDF viewer

---

## ✅ NEXT STEPS

1. **Immediate Actions:**
   - [ ] Verify database seeded
   - [ ] Create test accounts
   - [ ] Prepare test files
   - [ ] Start Phase 1 testing

2. **After Phase 1:**
   - [ ] Document all issues found
   - [ ] Fix critical bugs
   - [ ] Retest failed cases

3. **After All Testing:**
   - [ ] Create final test report
   - [ ] Recommend improvements
   - [ ] Prepare for UAT

---

**Test Status:** 🟡 In Progress (Structure Verified)
**Next Test:** TC-SR-001 (Skripsi Registration)